Original Sin: Giordano Bruno Against Augustin-Lutheran Tradition

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

Department of Philosophy, Faculty of Literature and Foreign Languages, University of Allame Tabataba'i, Tehran, Iran

Abstract

Christianity is based upon the idea of original sin. In other words, Christianity began by establishing a doctrine for the sin which is executed by Adam and Eva. In different eras, Christian theologians and before them, Church’s Fathers, tried to formulate this idea in a justificatory manner and to find a way for human salvation. The summit of these efforts could be seen in Saint Augustin and Luther writings. But, in the renaissance era, their approach converted and lead to another way and the thinkers of this age tried to revise the idea of original sin. One of these thinkers is Giordano Bruno. He disputed with Lutheran tradition and announced that this idea is false. In this article, first we try to sum up Bruno’s arguments and then we analyze phrases from Bible which is deeply related to the idea and by doing this we shall try to enforce Bruno’s thesis and to show in which way he was right. In the conclusion, we make this point evident that the revision Bruno made, lead Renaissance to a new kind of believing in God and by asserting this it will be intelligible that contrary to common beliefs, Renaissance rather than being era of leaving God behind the doors of Church, is the era of deification of every single part of World.

Keywords

Main Subjects

References

  1. ابن‏سینا (1387). الالهیات من کتاب الشفاء. محقق: آیت‌الله حسن حسن‌زاده آملی. قم: بوستان کتاب.

    Ansaldi, S. (2013). L'imagination fantastique: images, ombres et miroirs à la Renaissance. Paris: Les Belles lettres.

    -------- (2017). Nature et Puissance. Editions Kimé. Paris.

    Asclepius (1945). in Corpus Hermeticum (XIII-XVIII). Les Belles Lettres. Paris.

    Biblia Hebraica Stuttgartensia (1997). German Bible Society. Compact edition.

    Biblia Sacra (2005). Londen: edition electronica.

    Borne, É. (1991). Le Problème du mal. France. Presses universitaires de France.

    Carannante, S. (2018). Unigenita Natura: Dio e Universo in Giordano Bruno. Edizioni di Storia e Lettera Tura. Roma.

    de Plinval, G. (1936). PÉLAGE et LES PREMIERS ASPECTS DU PÉLAGIANISME. Revue Des Sciences Philosophiques et Théologiques, 25(3), 429–458.

    Deschamps Lucienne. Le chant V du De rerum natura de Lucrèce et Varron de Reate. In: Vita Latina, N°151, 1998. pp. 6-18.

    Erasmus, D. (1910). De libero arbitrio diatribē, sive collatio. Germany: A. Deichert (G. Böhme).

    Giordano Bruno (1958). Dialoghi Italiani. Sensoni. Fierenze.

    Granada, M. A. (1994). Il Rifiuto Della Distinzione Fra “Potentia Absoluta” E “Potentia Ordinata” Di Dio E L’affermazione Dell’universo Infinito In Giordano Bruno. Rivista Di Storia Della Filosofia (1984-), 49(3), 495–532.

    Kobusch, T. (2021). The Possible and the Impossible: Potentia absoluta and potentia ordinata Under Close Scrutiny. In L. Schumacher (Ed.), The Legacy of Early Franciscan Thought (pp. 207-220). Berlin. Boston: De Gruyter.

    1. A. Granada, L’infinité de l’univers et la conception du système solaire chez Giordano Bruno, «Revue des sciences philosophiques et théologiques», 1998/2, LXXXII, pp. 243-275.
    2. Cilberto, La ruota del tempo. Interpretazione di Giordano Bruno, Rome, Editori Riuniti, 1986 (2000), 154-207.

    Martin Luther (2006). Von der Freiheit eines Christenmenschen. Gütersloher Verlagshaus, Gütersloh.

    ------------ (1908). De servo arbitrio. In: D. Martin Luthers Werke. Kritische Gesamtausgabe. Band 18. Weimar: Böhlau.

    Minois, G. (2002). Les origines du mal. Fayard, Paris.

    Novum Testamentum Graece (2012). Nestle-Aland, German Bible Society; 28th Revised ed.

    Peshitta: Genesis (2019). ed. George A. Kiraz & Andreas Juckel, Gorgias Press.

    Rouche, M. & Balard, M. (2021). Les origines du christianisme: 30-451. France: Hachette supérieur.

    Schaff, P. (1878). The Greek and Latin creeds, with translations. United States: Harper.

     

    References

    Ansaldi, Saverio (2013). The fantastic imagination: images, shadows and mirrors in the Renaissance. Paris: Belles lettres. [in French]

    Ansaldi, Saverio (2017), Nature and Potentiality, Editions Kimé, Paris. [in French]

    Asclepius (1945) in Corpus Hermeticum (XIII-XVIII), Les Belles Lettres, Paris. [in Greek]

    Biblia Hebraica Stuttgartensia (1997), German Bible Society; Compact edition. [in Hebrew]

    Biblia Sacra (2005), Londen: electronica edition. [in Latin]

    Borne, É. (1991). The Problem of Evil. France: Presses universitaires de France (réédition numérique FeniXX). “[in French]

    Carannante, Salvatore (2018), Only-begotten Nature: God and Universe in Giordano Bruno; Edizioni di Storia e Lettera Tura, Roma. [in Italian]

    de Plinval, G. (1936). PELAGE and THE FIRST ASPECTS OF PELAGIANISM. Revue Des Sciences Philosophiques et Théologique, 25(3), 429–458. [in French]

    Deschamps Lucienne. Canto V of De rerum natura by Lucrezia and Varro by Reate. In: Vita Latina, N°151, 1998. pp. 6-18. [in Latin]

    Erasmus, D. (1910). On Free Will. Germany: A. Deichert (G. Böhme). [in Latin]

    Giordano Bruno (1958), Italian Dialogues, Sensoni, Fierenze. [in Italian]

    Granada, M.A. (1994). THE REJECTION OF THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN "POTENTIA ABSOLUTA" AND "POTENTIA ORDINATA" OF GOD AND THE AFFIRMATION OF THE INFINITE UNIVERSE IN GIORDANO BRUNO. Rivista Di Storia Della Filosofia (1984-), 49(3), 495–532. [in Italian]

    Ibn Sina (2008), Theology Treatise from The Book of Healing, ed. Hassan Hassnazadeh Amolli, Qom; Bustan-e-Ketab. [in Arabic]

    Kobusch, T. (2021). The Possible and the Impossible: Potentia absoluta and potentia ordinata Under Close Scrutiny. In L. Schumacher (Ed.), The Legacy of Early Franciscan Thought (pp. 207-220). Berlin, Boston: De Gruyter. [in English]

    1. A. Granada, The infinity of the universe and the conception of the solar system in Giordano Bruno, “Revue des sciences philosophiques et théologiques”, 1998/2, LXXXII, pp. 243-275 [in french]
    2. Cilberto, The Wheel of Time. Interpretation by Giordano Bruno, Rome, Editori Riuniti, 1986 (2000), p. 154-207. [in Italian]

    Martin Luther (2006) On Freedom of Christian. Gütersloher Verlagshaus, Gütersloh. [in German]

    Martin Luther, (1908) On The Enslaved Will. In: D. Martin Luthers Werke. Kritische Gesamtausgabe. Band 18, Weimar: Böhlau. [in Latin]

    Minois, Georges (2002), The origins of evil, Fayard, Paris. [in French]

    Novum Testamentum Graece (2012): Nestle-Aland, German Bible Society; 28th Revised ed. [in koine Greek]

    Peshitta: Genesis (2019), ed. George A. Kiraz & Andreas Juckel, Gorgias Press. [in classical Syriac]

    Rouche, M., Balard, M. (2021). The origins of Christianity: 30-451. France: Hachette superior. [in French]

    Schaff, P. (1878). The Greek and Latin creeds, with translations. United States: Harper. [in Latin and Greek]

Philosophy of Religion
Volume 20, Issue 4
January 2024
Pages 299-310

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics